Sunday, October 21, 2018

What Do We Do When Our Truths Aren't the Same?

What do we do when our truths aren't the same?
When my daughter was young I would often notice how different our truths were.  It was not uncommon to find myself frustrated by her take on the way things had happened.  She worried about things that, in my opinion, weren't really about her and, yet, have difficulty taking responsibility for her part in events.  Often I felt she wasn't being honest with me in conversations, but across time I began to realize she truly had a different perception of the way many things happened.  I could be in a room with her when something happened yet her perception of the event was always so different from mine.  She had a soft heart so often things that happened felt very personal to her.  Of course, my truth came from a different place of experience.  Over the years, I had to learn to take my truth out of the conversation and try to understand her truth.

As educators, we often sit beside people who have a different truth than we have.  Whether working with our teams, sitting with parents, or listening to specialists we can find our truths do not match.  Whether teaching, coaching, or leading, we run up against those who have a different way of seeing situations.  So often in these situations it seems we choose a fight or flight strategy.  I've watched people shut down when someone begins muscling their truth into situations.  I've seen people dig their heels in when faced with a truth different from the truth they hold.  This can lead to "this or that" confrontations when the truth - and the solution - is likely somewhere in the middle.  We see these extreme poles in conversations of phonics, technology, grammar, timed fact tests, conventions, and other educational hot-button topics.

What do we do when our truths aren't the same?


Five Tips to Help Us When Our Truths Aren't the Same


  1. Listen More, Talk Less: I've been in enough situations where once I unraveled a truth I could begin to see the point of view of the person beside me that I've learned to listen more and talk less when my truth doesn't match the person beside me.
  2. Ask Questions: When our truths don't match, it's hard not too over-infer or read more into what is being said. This is why this is the perfect time to start asking questions to help to better understand. So often after asking clarifying questions I begin to understand more the other person's point of view.
  3. Stay Curious: Instead of trying to be right, if we work to stay curious we can begin to work toward understanding the point of view of others. In our work, this is essential to finding better solutions to complicated challenges.  
  4. Build a Bridge:  Listening more, asking questions, and staying curious can help us to build a bridge to a common truth, understanding or solution.
  5. Find the Place Where You Stand Closer to Common Ground: There is always a common truth somewhere in what two people believe. Sometimes it just takes a bit of conversation to find it.

My daughter went to college and graduated with a degree in social-justice advocacy. She has learned to see everything from the perspective of others. Now it is she that often reminds me of the other points of view in this complicated world of opinions. I like to think all of those conversations as she grew up made her the advocate for others that she can be. She's learned to use these strategies above to understand the truth of the person sitting beside her. Her experiences have helped her to develop skills for handling difficult conversations. She weighs her words carefully, asks thoughtful questions, and works to level the conversation.

We certainly live in a time where people hold tightly to their truths, but what could be improved if we learned to listen more when our truths aren't the same?



5 comments:

  1. Having had the pleasure of sitting beside you in meetings, across from you in coffee shops, and sometimes sharing car trips, I know all to well how you’ve always been a thoughtful listener. I’d say your daughter has had an excellent mentor right there in the family room! You’ve inspired me to listen more and to listen to understand.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I stumbled upon this quote about listening, and thought it spoke to this point: "Listening means taking a second to consider what they're saying, not just hearing their words." http://www.favething.com/g-newman/quotes/quote-on-listening/

      Loved it!

      Delete
  2. I'm currently reading a book called Truth: How the Many Sides to Every Story Shape Our Reality by Hector Macdonald. I've been finding this topic fascinating of late. I think that your advice on the subject is excellent. I wish more people made this effort, instead of just digging in on their own "truth". Thanks for writing about this!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I've downloaded a sample of this book. I certainly love its premise. I hope you'll share what you think when you finish reading it.

      Delete
  3. I finished Hector Macdonald's Truth today, Cathy. Bottom line: I agreed with his central tenet ("There is usually more than one true way to talk about something. We can use competing truths constructively to engage people and inspire action, but we should also watch out for communicators who use competing truths to mislead us."). It's well-researched and covers a lot of persuasion / spin / truth related ground. But the book itself was a little longer than it needed to be for me (or I wasn't as interested as I thought) - I got bogged down at times and had to switch to something else. Still, I did finish, which is not always the case with nonfiction titles for me.

    ReplyDelete